Proposals for an multinational security mission authorized by the UN to disarm Hamas in Gaza are encountering growing resistance after the UAE announced it would not join due to the absence of a well-defined legal framework.
Increasing Global Reservations
Israeli authorities have previously excluded Turkish participation, and Jordan's King Abdullah has stated that Jordanian forces will not participate. The Azerbaijani government, previously considered as a potential contributor, was absent from a planning session in Istanbul and said it would not take part unless a full ceasefire was established.
The UAE does not yet see a defined framework for the stabilisation force and under such circumstances declines involvement, but will support all political efforts towards resolution – and remain at the vanguard of humanitarian aid.
Arab Skepticism and Legal Concerns
The UAE's announcement, delivered by senior envoy Dr Anwar Gargash at a conference in Abu Dhabi, reflects Arab reservations about the terms of a US-drafted document already circulated to diplomats at the UN in NYC. The proposal places an onus on a American-led security mission to be the principal means of imposing order in Gaza after Israel have left the region.
Arab states would like greater duties to be assigned to a separate Palestinian law enforcement agency. International law would also forbid foreign troops from deploying into contested Palestine unless there was clear local approval; otherwise, the force could be seen as coercive under international statutes, and arguably stabilising an unlawful Israeli occupation.
Local Perspectives and Appeals for Definition
Jamal Nusseibeh of the ceasefire proposal said: “It is essential that the force be deployed not to stabilise the unlawful presence, but to enforce global standards and end it. The mission will work as long as it operates in the entire occupied territory, including the West Bank, at the invitation of Palestine, and has a defined objective to conclude the presence within the context of a independent Palestinian state.”
The draft contains no reference to the occupied territories in the US draft resolution, or to a Palestinian state, or a two-state solution, a prospect that Israel rejects.
Continuing Negotiations and Potential Risks
Detailed negotiations on the stabilisation force mandate, including its leadership structure, started formally on Thursday in the UN headquarters, and look likely to be protracted – potentially creating the development of a power gap in the strip that may empower Hamas.
The US is suggesting that it command the mission although it will not have a large number of troops deployed on the ground. It has previously effectively taken control of the delivery of relief supplies into the territory from a new civil military coordination centre based in Israel.
Force Mandate and Governance Function
The draft US resolution defines the aim of the security mission as “along with the newly trained and vetted police force to assist in protecting frontier zones, stabilise the security environment in the region by ensuring the process of disarming the territory including the elimination and prevention of reconstructing the militant and offensive infrastructure as well as the lasting removal of weapons from militant factions”.
The mission, reporting to a “peace council” chaired by the former US president, and not to the United Nations, would be mandated to use “any required actions” to achieve its objectives.
Regional powers including Qatar are also concerned that this authority is overly broad, and if Hamas is to disarm, the group will solely do so to fellow Palestinians, probably in the local law enforcement, at a moment that, from the militant viewpoint, signifies the conclusion of occupation.
They also worry the draft mandate spills into granting the mission a administrative role in Gaza, a responsibility that was to be set aside for a local expert panel working in cooperation with a reformed Palestinian Authority.
Humanitarian Aspects and Financial Questions
This “transitional governance administration” in Gaza would remain until “the Palestinian Authority has satisfactorily finished its restructuring plan, the satisfaction of which shall be acceptable to the BoP”, the draft states. It also “underscores the importance” of unhindered humanitarian aid in the territory, including through the United Nations, the International Committee of the Red Cross, and the Red Crescent.
However, it allows for the exclusion of “any organisation determined to have misused such aid”. The phrase leaves open the council barring Unrwa, the body that the international court of justice has ruled is the legal provider of aid.
Global Political Initiatives
French officials and Saudi Arabia are already advocating for a reference to a Palestinian state to be added in the document. The Saudi leader, Mohammed bin Salman, is scheduled in the White House on 18 November, and Manal Radwan has said that a reference to a independent Palestine is a requirement.
The Palestinian Authority leader, Mahmoud Abbas, held talks with the French leader, Emmanuel Macron, in the French capital on this week to discuss the authority's function.
Neither the United Nations nor the 15 strong security council are assigned a supervisory function over the mission, supervising the implementation of the resolution, a point mostly overlooked by the draft text. No details is outlined about the financing of this security operation, which, according to the US officials, should be mostly covered by Gulf states, with the Kingdom taking the lead.
Israel's Demands and Regional Developments
Israeli authorities is requesting formal assurances from the United States that it be allowed to follow the model of the Lebanese situation and retain the right to re-enter the territory if it believes disarmament is not taking place at a scale or pace it demands.
The Israeli proposal was presented to Jared Kushner, the ex-president's relative, and the American diplomat, Steve Witkoff. Kushner was in the Israeli capital on Monday to review developments on the truce and the envoy was due to appear subsequently the that day.
Only the remains of four of the original hundreds of Israeli hostages are still unreturned.
Independently, Israeli officials has been suggesting that the Gaza Strip could still be split in two parts with reconstruction work starting in the Israel occupied areas of the region. Western diplomats insist that this is no part of the former US administration's proposal.